I did not review this year’s Doctor Who on initial viewing. I’ve decided that my first impressions are too emotional and subjective, far beyond the fact that all criticism is subjective on some level. It’s too easy to get sucked into “different = heretical” (or “same = boring” for that matter). I hope to review the 2020 season here soon, but I realised I never reviewed Resolution! I watched it again last night. Here we go!
Early on there’s an attempt to tap into classic Doctor Who horror tropes. There’s some solid tunnel work early on and the scene of the possessed Lin in her bathroom was very effective, genuinely sounding like she was about to throw up in disgust at what was happening to her.
Unfortunately, this rapidly became one of those stories where a science fiction threat is married to an emotional subplot that has no plot or thematic connection to it. I’ve never really seen the wisdom of this. I feel the emotional core of the episode should relate more directly to the science fiction plot. Neither of the plot lines is particularly bad here, but they do not really gel either, especially with no sign of Aaron becoming a semi-regular whose experience with a Dalek might become relevant.
The juxtaposition between the Dalek killing two police officers and Aaron trying to sell a microwave/oven was effective, if not especially challenging. New Year’s Day viewing perhaps requires a degree of familiarity in the tropes used. There was a danger of Aaron becoming the cliché of the black man who abandons his family, but this is rescued by Daniel Adegboyega’s thoughtful performance as a man with regrets who is realising that he has made some serious mistakes with his life.
Surprisingly, the action seemed lower down in the mix than the emotion, a feature that may be budgetary as there seemed surprisingly few soldiers while GCHQ was represented by one extra in a single room. At least we did not have an Action Man tank this time. And an ill-advised joke near the climax about families needing to relearn the art of conversation was (a) not funny, (b) old, and (c) distracting from the climax of the story.
There was some handwaving of plot points too, possibly to keep the two separate plot strands running at the same time. Presumably the Dalek learnt where its gun was from its internet searching, but it was not completely clear about where it had been for the previous thousand years until it was bought by MDZ.
In the end the Dalek was defeated and Aaron and Ryan reconciled, as we knew all along would happen. The problem is that it is not at all clear whether Aaron has really changed, something reinforced by his non-appearance in 2020. Has anyone really moved on? It’s hard to tell, which makes this seem a bit like something happening on the television rather than in real life.
I don’t wish to sound too negative. Resolution was a success overall, especially as our only new TV Doctor Who for 2019. It was worth holding back this Doctor’s first meeting with the Daleks to make it count off-screen as well as on-screen, turning the only episode of the year into more of an event. I just wish that Aaron could have been integrated into the plot a bit more.
I was surprised at the hate that greeted the bit about UNIT being suspended at the time of broadcast, as it seemed to me a fairly obvious way of explaining why they weren’t around so that we could focus on the Doctor in this incarnation’s first battle against the Daleks. I doubt that they will be out of commission for long. I am also unsure why people saw it as a Brexit joke, when it seemed to me to be more about austerity in general or, more likely, Donald Trump’s threats to pull the USA out of NATO. The Dalek apparently accessed the Black Archive on Lin’s computer, which indicated to me that UNIT may not be as out of reach as Polly thought.
I know I’m not the only person who has wondered how Medieval knights killed a Dalek. Was it the brother of the rubbish Dalek who blew up when shot with spears and arrows in Death to the Daleks?
I liked the matter-of-fact way Graham says “Alien psychopath.” You can almost hear him thinking, “Another of those nutters.”